Acute to Chronic Islamophobia:the impact and mitigation of counter-extremism on young Muslims in Northern Europe

Abstract

This paper examines the evolving role of the counterterrorism state in Islamophobia across Northern Europe, exploring how new preventative counterextremism measures have reshaped Islamophobia from acute articulations of violence to chronic social exclusion and how young Muslims have sought to respond. Drawing on 114 interviews with young Muslims aged 18–25 in the UK, Netherlands, Denmark, and Norway, along with eight subsequent focus groups, the research highlights how counterterrorism policies are normalising anti-Muslim attitudes and constructing young Muslims as latent security threats in novel ways. These findings reveal significant shifts: while acute articulations of Islamophobia, marked by reports of physical acts of anti-Muslim violence, have notably declined, structural and institutional forms – understood here as chronic forms of Islamophobia have become more dominant. This shift is intricately tied to the evolution of state-led counterextremism and pre-crime programmes that perpetuate radicalisation narratives, alienating young Muslims and fostering disengagement from political and media spheres. The paper furthermore seeks to understand the agency of young Muslims, finding that they have developed new strategies for managing and mitigating chronic articulations of Islamophobia. By bringing together theories on securitisation, Islamophobia and racialisation, the authors underscore the need for critical revaluation of new and ongoing counterextremism approaches, their societal implications, and how young Muslims seek to manage and mitigate novel patterns of racialisation and social exclusion.