How unlucky is 25-sigma?

Dowd, Kevin, Cotter, John, Humphrey, Christopher and Woods, Margaret (2008). How unlucky is 25-sigma? Journal of Portfolio Management, 34 (4), pp. 76-80.


Purpose - To identify the likelihood of a 25-standard deviation occurring in stock prices over several successive days, in the light of comments by David Viniar, chief financial officer of Goldman Sachs.. Design/methodology/approach - Assumes a bell-curve of market losses and graphs the probability of an event relative to the number of deviations. Calculates using MATLAB for sigmas over 7. Considers whether the losses of US investment banks in 2008 were the result of bad luck or of incompetence. Findings - Finds that the probability of a 25-sigma event is every 100,000 +130 decimal points years. Practical implications - Argues that bad luck is usually associated with incompetence, and investors need not choose between them. Originality/value - Presents the mathematical absurdity of a finance officer's statement, and its implications.

Publication DOI:
Divisions: Aston Business School > Accounting
Aston Business School > Accounting Research Group
Uncontrolled Keywords: Business, Management and Accounting(all),Accounting,Economics and Econometrics,Finance
Full Text Link:
Related URLs:
Published Date: 2008-06
Authors: Dowd, Kevin
Cotter, John
Humphrey, Christopher
Woods, Margaret


Item under embargo

Export / Share Citation


Additional statistics for this record